Share from 0:00
0:00
/

A Roundtable Discussion on Gyges’ Ring (357a-362c)

Could You Be Crucified for Justice? A Conversation with Dr. Paul Diduch

Would you still be just if no one was watching?

What if you could do whatever you wanted and never suffer the consequences?

And if justice is only useful for its effects, why not take the reputation and leave the reality?

On Ascend, we already walked through the basic shape of Glaucon’s challenge with Dr. Jennifer Frey. This roundtable conversation with Dr. Paul Diduch of SMU is different. It is a slower, richer conversation about what the passage is really doing and who is speaking it. Glaucon is introduced as “most courageous.” Does that single line change how you hear the rest of his speech? Is the extreme picture he paints—the just man who is whipped, racked, and crucified—also a test he is putting to himself? Could he endure that for justice?

Join our slow read-along of Plato’s Republic!

. Check out the full reading schedule here.

To support our mission and get all our resources, become a paid book club member. In addition to the weekly podcast, you’ll get:

  • Live book club discussions with Dcn. Garlick & guest scholars (monthly)

  • In-depth reading guides and essays to lead you through the great books

  • Access to our incredible community of readers

  • The full archive of members-only content (guides, essays, and podcasts)

Dr. Grabowski asks whether the shepherd already reveals his nature before he ever puts the ring on. Thomas Lackey brings in a range of literary parallels, including St. Ambrose’s reading of the just man who suffers. Dr. Larson traces the social-compact argument forward to Hobbes and asks how close Glaucon’s anthropology really is to the modern version. Dr. Diduch presses on whether Glaucon is fully coherent or already divided against himself, and he names the three questions the rest of the Republic will still have to answer: the origin of the city, the hope for inner harmony, and the superlative hope that justice can answer even death.

If you have already heard the first episode on this section, this one is still worth your time. It stays closer to the text, presses harder on the man who is speaking, and leaves you with clearer questions for the books that follow. The passage continues to set the terms for everything else in the Republic.

Come listen and wrestle with it again.

Be sure to check out our entire reading schedule (it is revised at times if we have to reschedule a recording).

God bless.


Dcn. Harrison Garlick lives in rural Oklahoma with his wife and five children. He serves as a deacon at Holy Family Cathedral and as Chancellor & General Counsel for the Roman Catholic Diocese of Tulsa. Follow him on X at Dcn. Garlick or Ascend.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?